American International Group (AIG) Claim Denials Attorney

Denied Under an American International Group Disability Policy?

Disability insurance claims issued by AIG can be denied or terminated despite substantial medical and occupational evidence supporting disability. These claims often involve long term disability policies governed by ERISA, where insurers are required to follow specific procedural and substantive standards when making benefit decisions.

Federal courts reviewing disability insurance disputes have examined whether AIG properly evaluated medical records, fairly considered treating physician opinions, and correctly applied policy definitions when denying or terminating benefits.

Eric Buchanan & Associates has extensive experience representing policyholders nationwide in disability insurance claims, including claims involving AIG, and challenging benefit decisions that the insurance company claims are unsupported by the evidence or inconsistent with the policy terms.

Documented History Of AIG Claim Practices

Federal courts reviewing disability insurance claims administered by AIG have examined whether benefit determinations were supported by the administrative record and made in accordance with ERISA requirements. In multiple cases, courts have scrutinized AIG’s evaluation of medical evidence, vocational assessments, and the reasoning used to deny or terminate long term disability benefits.

Judicial decisions have highlighted concerns where AIG relied heavily on non examining medical reviewers, discounted treating physician opinions without adequate explanation, or failed to reconcile conflicting evidence within the claim record. Courts have also reviewed whether AIG properly considered the claimant’s actual occupational demands when applying the policy’s definition of disability.

This documented history of judicial review underscores that disability insurers must conduct a full and fair evaluation of claims and base benefit decisions on reasoned analysis rather than selective interpretation of the evidence. Where courts find that AIG failed to meet these standards, benefit denials may be overturned or remanded for further review.

American International Group’s Claim Practices And Legal History

Federal courts have examined how American International Group has evaluated disability claims. In Rasenack ex rel. Tribolet v. AIG Life Insurance Company, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed AIG’s denial of a disability claim involving a diagnosis of hemiplegia.

The court concluded that AIG selectively relied on portions of the administrative record while disregarding consistent medical opinions from treating and examining professionals. The court also determined that AIG failed to conduct a sufficiently thorough investigation before denying benefits.


See Our Happy Client Reviews


Financial Pressure on Claim Decision Makers

Long term disability claims can represent substantial financial exposure for insurers, particularly when benefits are payable for many years or through retirement age. For insurers administering ERISA governed plans, ongoing benefit payments may involve significant long term obligations.

Courts reviewing disability insurance disputes have recognized that insurers operate within financial frameworks that can influence how claims are evaluated and reviewed. These pressures may become more pronounced in claims involving extended benefit durations or ongoing medical conditions.

Judicial scrutiny of benefit determinations reflects the importance of separating financial considerations from fair and impartial claim evaluation. When courts find that benefit decisions are not supported by the administrative record, those decisions may be overturned or remanded for further review.

How We Approach American International Group Disability Claims

Disability claims administered by AIG require a detailed, policy specific approach. Many AIG disability claims are governed by ERISA and are subject to strict procedural requirements that control how evidence is evaluated and preserved for judicial review.

Our approach begins with a careful analysis of the plan language to determine the exact standards AIG is required to apply. We then assess how the insurer reviewed the medical and vocational evidence and whether its conclusions are supported by the administrative record.

When handling AIG disability claims, we focus on building a clear and well documented record that demonstrates functional limitations and occupational impact under the applicable policy definitions. This includes developing medical evidence, addressing mischaracterizations in the claim file, and responding to opinions from non examining medical reviewers.

We also identify procedural deficiencies and preserve issues for litigation when necessary. By positioning claims for effective judicial review, we work to ensure that disability benefit determinations comply with applicable law and the terms of the policy.

Our Role As Advocates

The court decisions discussed on this page illustrate how judges evaluate disability claims involving Hartford and Aetna by closely examining policy language, the administrative record, and the standards applied when determining eligibility for benefits.

Eric Buchanan & Associates represents disability insurance policyholders nationwide in ERISA governed long term disability claims. Our role is to advocate for individuals whose disability benefits have been denied, delayed, or terminated despite documented medical and vocational evidence.

We guide clients through each stage of the disability claim process, from initial claim evaluation through appeal and litigation when necessary. Our work focuses on enforcing the terms of the policy and ensuring that insurers follow required claim procedures and legal standards.

When disability claims are not evaluated fairly or in accordance with the law, we act to hold insurers accountable through the administrative and judicial review process. Our commitment is to protect our clients’ rights and pursue the benefits they relied on when securing disability insurance coverage.

Contact Us Today!

You don’t have to deal with the insurance company alone. If your claim was denied, delayed, or handled unfairly, our team is ready to review your case and help you understand your next steps.
Call: (877) 634-2506